The chickens have come home to roost for a continent that gambled its future on endless confrontation. With Washington packing its bags and Moscow holding all the cards, European leaders have been cut out of the loop, watching great powers carve up their continent’s destiny from afar.
The Death of the Unipolar Illusion
The “Land-for-NATO” Ploy
The recent 10-11 November 2026, US brokered peace talks between Russia and Ukraine that have clarified one thing to the West: Kyiv, having been utilized as a Western proxy against Russia, has lost the conflict on the battlefield. The West has now understood that supplying more arms and ammunition to Ukraine would not be fruitful and will not change the ground situation. Thus, to save itself from humiliation, the US has proposed a controversial offer to Ukraine—to give up its territory, in particular the Donbas region, in exchange for NATO membership.
In an interview, Ukrainian President Zelensky explicitly mentioned, “The Americans raised a question: ‘What if Ukraine joins NATO? Would Ukraine withdraw from Donbas?’ This was the first time this had been raised.” To date, Zelensky has raised several conditions, including a referendum and security guarantees, to accept this offer. However, this land-for-NATO proposal is nothing more than ‘a desperate Hail Mary pass.’ It’s a cynical way of face-saving. The US is basically trying to end its failed proxy conflict by providing land concessions that Russia has already taken control of so that it can somehow retain its military foothold still on the Russian borders.
Moscow’s Red Lines and the Return to December 2021
The Russian Federation has categorically rejected the ‘Land-for-NATO’ ploy of the US. Moscow has not borne the years of bloodshed and sanctions by the West just to accept the modified version of the NATO threat on its border, i.e., NATO 3.0. However, according to various media reports, during the recent meetup with President Trump’s envoys, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, Russian President Vladimir Putin has put on the table its ‘December 2021 security proposal’ for Europe. This draft has two main demands: first, to completely stop NATO’s eastward expansion, and second, NATO must roll back its military infrastructure to the 1997 borders.
To put simply, it’s the West whose demands have changed with time. Russia is still pursuing its traditional stance: the expulsion of NATO forces from post-1997 member states. Moreover, Russia also wants the expulsion of all American conventional and nonconventional military buildup from Eastern Europe, which is a direct threat to Russian national security and sovereignty. Crucially, Russia is not making these demands rigidly. It’s ready to provide reciprocal guarantees to the West, which might include removing its nuclear build up in Belarus and altering its current force posture in territories like Transnistria.
American Retrenchment Meets Russian Realism
Donald Trump’s worldview is a direct threat to the US allies, in particular the Europeans. Trump considers Europe a fiscal burden, having been enjoying free riding services from the US for decades. Although this perspective is not only associated with Trump, the strategic circles in the US also hold similar views, but Trump’s actions are more aggressive and unpredictable in this regard. Under the ‘America First’ policy, the Trump administration is seriously eyeing a sharp withdrawal of its forces and military infrastructure from Europe to be shifted to other areas, including the Western Hemisphere and the Asia-Pacific.
Therefore, the withdrawal of the NATO forces, in particular that of the US from the Eastern Europe is no more a political desire, rather it has become a practical necessity for Washington. Consequently, the American retrenchment coincides with the Russian-sponsored European security architecture – the 1997 rollback. Thus, what Russia wants from the West, the US is now compelled to do so as a necessity. For Europe, Trump’s desire to cut America’s losses abroad and Putin’s demand for a NATO rollback are effectively two sides of the same coin.
Brussels’ Self-Inflicted Irrelevance
So now, when ‘everything about Europe without Europe’ is practically taking place, Europeans are now trying to create their own negotiating bloc out of anxiety and fear. This calamity upon Europe is due to its own ruthless policies. By imposing strict sanctions and cutting all ways of negotiation with Moscow, Europe has destroyed its own economy and has become a vassal state whose voice no longer matters. The upcoming great powers’ trilateral summit in Shenzhen projects well this reality: that the era of Western dictation has finally ended. In essence, history offers a harsh lesson to Brussels—those who refuse to negotiate based on reality will inevitably have reality negotiated for them.
Taut Bataut is a researcher and writer who publishes on South Asian geopolitics
Follow new articles on our Telegram channel

