What appears to be an abrupt change of attitude is actually a long-standing reflex of a continent which has never properly come to grips with how they have gained their wealth, power and memory.

The Reckoning That Wasn’t: Colonialist Amnesia, Panics and the Two Europes
Any capital in Europe this autumn will have a similar feeling of nervousness. Germany’s AfD have just secured 43.8% in State elections. Washington is negotiating Ukraine’s future. A French court has allowed Marine Le Pen to run for the Élysée and the Mediterranean has once again become a site of death with the presence of a coastguard. This has been described by commentators as a ‘polycrisis’, an overly technical term and not really explaining anything.
I would argue, however, that what appears to be an abrupt change of attitude is actually a long-standing reflex of a continent which has never properly come to grips with how they have gained their wealth, power and memory. The first part of this article discusses the colonial past and migration panic. The second part looks at the rise of the right and the curious absence of the left. The third part considers Europe’s Nazi legacy including Ukraine, and how Europe is losing its geopolitical power. Every example below is from a different country.
Apologies Aren’t Reckonings
Europeans are very good at holding ceremonies. The Netherlands apologised in December 2022. Belgium’s king has expressed ‘deepest regrets’ for Congo. The Belgian state in June 2022 returned the last remnant of Patrice Lumumba, a gold capped tooth, to his family. In December 2022, the Dutch Prime Minister apologised and created a fund of €200 million, clearly stating descendants would not receive compensation. Germany and Namibia declared a joint statement on the genocide of the Herero and Nama people in 2021, however only ‘from today’s perspective’. Around €1.1 billion will go to the countries over thirty years. Representatives of the Herero and Nama people, who were excluded from the negotiations, state this is not reparations but development aid. In 2013, Britain paid 19.9 million to 5,228 Kenyans who were tortured during the Mau Mau uprising. It stated it ‘sincerely regrets’ the abuse, however denied legal responsibility.
Note how they use the words ‘regrets’, ‘expressed regrets’ and ‘declared’ — no-one uses the word owe.
France is the best example. In 2005, parliament passed legislation to teach students about the ‘positive role’ of colonisation abroad. However, this was heavily protested by historians and the clause was removed the following year. A decade later, a candidate named Emmanuel Macron stated that colonisation was a ‘crime against humanity’ in Algiers, and received heavy backlash from within his own country. The Algerian War of Independence, involving torture and hundreds of thousands of deaths, is still being negotiated within French politics as part of their national identity.
With the testimony of the rest of the world becoming harder to ignore, the United Nations General Assembly voted on 25 March 2026. A resolution was tabled by Ghana stating the transatlantic slave trade was the greatest crime against humanity and encouraged states to discuss apologies, returning artefacts, compensation and prevention of future occurrences. 123 voted in favour, whilst the United States, Israel and Argentina voted against. 52 abstained, including the United Kingdom and all EU member states according to Human Rights Watch. The British Government stated that they did not wish to create a ‘hierarchy of historical atrocities’. They also made it clear they would not pay reparations. Whilst this is not binding, Europe still struggled to even say yes to the word crime.
As Frantz Fanon wrote, ‘Europe is literally the creation of the Third World’. The wealth that suffocates Europe was stolen from the undeveloped nations. Walter Rodney and Eric Williams both wrote about this using statistics to show how Africa had been stunted in development and how sugar and cotton helped boost British industries. Although not all the theories in these books need to be taken on board, it is clear to see that if a political culture believes they are prosperous due to their own virtue then they cannot conceptualise this debt.
In Adam Hochschild’s book King Leopold’s Ghost, we can see how this debt is washed away. The Congo Free State was a privately owned state by one European monarch, however was sold to the reading public as a humanitarian mission to help stop slavery. Rubber quotas were enforced by taking hostages and amputations. It is estimated that millions died, and the exact number is still debated amongst historians. Hannah Arendt noted that the methods used in imperialism often come back to haunt Europeans, creating a ‘boomerang effect’. This will be discussed in part 3.
Migration Panics Are an Unpaid Debt
Let’s look at the panic around migration.
Beginning with war; NATO launched an air campaign in Libya in March 2011, with a Security Council mandate to protect civilians. This resulted in the collapse of the state and weaponry spilling out of the country. There were well over a thousand weapons depots according to American intelligence officials, as reported in Time magazine. Within hours of Gaddafi’s death, Tuareg fighters were heading back to Mali with truckloads of weapons. A UN report in early 2012 stated there was an increase in weapons proliferation, organised crime and terrorism throughout the Sahel. This led to increased instability in the south of the country (Sahel) and the smuggling routes in the north. Combined with the 2003 invasion of Iraq and the Syrian catastrophe where multiple European governments supported rebel factions, we have the three conflicts that have influenced the migrants arriving in 2015 onwards. Combined with the currency, the CFA franc. This has been controlled for decades by Paris. In 2019, the West African variant was renamed, the reserves were moved out of France and French representatives were removed from the central bank board. However, it still remained pegged to the Euro.
In 2025, the French army returned their bases in Chad, Ivory Coast and Senegal. They had previously been told to leave by the juntas of Mali, Burkina Faso and Niger, resulting in around 4,300 French soldiers leaving. The only permanent base France has in Africa is Djibouti. The policymakers in Paris refer to this as a reset, however the Africans involved refer to this as sovereignty.
Those who are actually displaced rarely end up in Europe. According to the UN refugee agency, around two thirds of the world’s refugees and those needing protection are hosted by low and middle income countries. Around 65% are hosted in a neighbouring country. The idea that Europe is bearing the brunt is a myth, but one that sells well politically.
Europe has responded by moving the border further out. Deals have been struck with Turkey, Libya and Tunisia to pay others to hold those before they get to the sea. The New Pact on migration and asylum, which has begun to be implemented this year, has increased speedier screening at the border. There are also so-called return hubs. These are centres in third countries which rejected applicants may be sent back to. Brussels state they are voluntary with safeguards in place. However, there is no doubt about the direction.
Italy is a great example of this. Giorgia Meloni’s government announced the ‘Mattei Plan’ shortly after coming into power. They are investing over €5.5 billion into energy, education and infrastructure in Africa. They have also signed a deal to manage two centres in Albania for migrants rescued at sea. Italian judges have repeatedly ruled these detentions cannot be validated. Development aid and border control share the same letterhead, and it’s easy to guess which one is the priority.
Josep Borrell, the EU’s former foreign policy chief, used an analogy in his speech to young diplomats in 2022. He said, ‘We are a garden and the rest of the world, mostly, is a jungle threatening to invade our garden. The jungle has a great capacity to grow, and the wall will never be high enough.’ He was commenting on Europe’s lack of engagement with the world. However, this shows how they see themselves. As gardeners, they are confused as to why the plants are invading. No-one planted the vines.
Donors, Recipients, and Indignants
It is important to note that the European Union isn’t one Europe.
There are those who pay. Germany, The Netherlands, Sweden, Denmark and Austria all contribute to the common budget, with four of them creating the ‘frugal’ bloc and haggling over the pandemic recovery fund. And there are those who receive. Poland is the biggest recipient, along with Romania, Bulgaria, Hungary and the Baltic States. Those who pay tend to have a colonial history, whilst those who receive generally don’t. Those who pay tend to give lectures, whilst those who receive tend to be annoyed by this. The money given to create cohesion has created a leash. As seen with Poland this autumn, the conditionality on rule of law freezes funding and penalties start to build up. Brussels doesn’t usually refer to this as leverage. They refer to it as values.
The East European countries have an interesting view on migration. In 2015, Hungary, Poland, Slovakia and Czechia refused to relocate asylum seekers. Three of them were ruled against by the EU Court of Justice in 2020. Their reasoning was sovereignty, however several leaders openly stated they were Muslims. Fast-forward to 2022, millions of Ukrainians crossed the same borders and were welcomed with open arms and free train tickets. Bulgaria’s Prime Minister, Kiril Petkov, told journalists they were Europeans, smart and educated. ‘This isn’t the kind of refugee wave we are used to.’ In 2021, hundreds of Syrians and Iraqis were left stranded in the freezing forests on the Polish-Belarusian border. Aid groups and journalists weren’t allowed in. It seems that hospitality here has a skin colour.
This doesn’t make Eastern Europe the villains of colonialism. They have been dominated by the Habsburgs and the Ottomans for centuries. They have a valid sense of innocence. However, this doesn’t mean they aren’t affected by the mindset of empire. During interwar Poland, there was a Maritime and Colonial League. They campaigned for overseas territories. In 1937, the Government sent a commission to Madagascar to see if Polish Jews could be settled there. The East wasn’t immune to the European idea of belonging, they just didn’t have the ships.
Thus, you have a continent split on who should pay and who should lecture, but agree on one thing.
Innocence as an Identity
Gloria Wekker, a Dutch scholar, refers to this mindset as ‘white innocence’. This is the national narrative of tolerance and decency, making the colonial history feel like it isn’t theirs. Michel-Rolph Trouillot went on to explain that those in power decide what can and cannot be remembered. Europe’s curricula, statues and museums all form an archive.
This is where the identity comes from. A continent who sees themselves as the birthplace of rights and reason struggle to accept that these rights were selectively given and reason was selectively applied. When pressure is put on them, by refugees, African governments wanting Paris to leave and a Global South voting for reparations, they don’t feel like they’re being charged. They feel like an attack on their identity.
This is important to Brussels, Berlin and Paris. When your identity is attacked you look for someone to blame and someone to protect you. This will be discussed in Part 2.
Tamer Mansour, Egyptian Independent Writer & Researcher
Follow new articles on our Telegram channel
