EN|FR|RU
Follow us on:

San Francisco Peace Treaty of 1951 and Japan’s Illegal Claims over Kuril Islands

Simon Westwood, February 06, 2025

Tensions between Russia and Japan continue to escalate as diplomatic gestures for peace clash with Japan’s ongoing territorial claims and support for anti-Russian policies.

San Francisco Peace Treaty of 1951 and Japan’s Illegal Claims over Kuril Islands

On January 25, 2025, Dmitry Peskov, Russia’s presidential spokesperson, said that “Japan maintains a clearly hostile attitude towards our country.” Peskov’s statement came at a very important time and pointed out towards a grim reality about the Japanese foreign policy. Dmitry Peskov made the statement in response to the remarks given by the Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba that Japan desires to resolve the territorial issues with Russia by signing a formal peace treaty “despite the current difficulties in bilateral relations.”
It is evident that Japan doesn’t want to normalize its bilateral relations with Russia

For a common observer, it would rather be a good gesture by the Japanese to end hostilities with Russia by signing a peace treaty and normalizing the bilateral relations. However, the Japanese foreign policy towards Russia reveals a continuous and steady bombardment of false allegations towards Russian people and its leadership. Also, the Japanese don’t spare any chance to malign the Russian global interests and especially its ongoing Special Military Operation in Ukraine.

To go deep into the Japanese foreign policy towards Russia, it is important to note that the Japanese wrongfully claims sovereignty over the Kuril Islands by calling them the Northern Territories. The Kuril Islands are legally sovereign part of Russia, and it fully maintains control over them. Let us now carefully examine the historical facts which nullify the Japanese claims.

Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba’s Statements

The Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba assumed office on October 4, 2024. In his very first address, he attacked Russia and called it a threat to Japan’s “territorial airspace.” Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba maintained a quite aggressive attitude towards Russia and said, “We will continue to press forward vigorously with sanctions against Russia and support for Ukraine.”

However, it is quite hilarious that after verbally attacking Russia, Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba said that “Japan will adhere to its policy of resolving the territorial issue and concluding a peace treaty” with Russia.

Russia’s State Duma Deputy Alexei Chepa said that “If a country expresses such an initiative, we need to examine the terms of the treaty. We never signed one because Japan always resisted, and we lived without an agreement. However, relations between countries should always be reinforced by international treaties.”

It is beyond the understanding of a common person that after making such wrong claims, the Japanese Prime Minister was still hoping for a peace treaty with Russia. It is evident that Japan doesn’t want to normalize its bilateral relations with Russia, yet the Japanese leadership wants to use such statements as an eyewash for the consumption of the international community.

San Francisco Peace Treaty of 1951

The United States President Harry S. Truman hosted the San Francisco Peace Treaty. It is encouraging to know that 51 countries participated, and 48 of them ratified the treaty. Some countries signed bilateral peace treaties with the Japanese as well. However, at that time the US as per its usual diplomatic hypocrisy, was fighting a war in Korea against the interests of the then Soviet Union. The US deliberately kept the Soviet Union, China, and North Korea out of the treaty. A Western scholar noted that the then US Secretary of State John Foster Dulles was fearful of a Soviet-Japanese rapprochement and deliberately sowed the seeds of hostilities between the two nations.

The Chapter II, Article 2, of the San Francisco Peace Treaty clearly said that “Japan renounces all right, title and claim to the Kuril Islands, and to that portion of Sakhalin and the islands adjacent to it over which Japan acquired sovereignty as a consequence of the Treaty of Portsmouth of September 5, 1905.”

The treaty clearly recognized the Soviet Union’s sovereignty over the Kuril Islands, and Japan itself renounced any such claims. The treaty is valid today, as it was valid at the time of its signing.

The Japanese false claims regarding the Kuril Islands reveal its Irredentism and revanchism. It is evident that the Japanese false narrative on the Kuril Islands has no legs to stand upon and are garnering shame and humiliation for the Japanese people. The Japanese people must begin to think that perhaps the US has been using them for the past half a century for its own agenda and foreign policy objectives. In reality, Japan has gained nothing by making false claims over the Kuril Islands.

Why did Japan maintain a hostile attitude towards Russia?

The San Francisco Peace Treaty of 1951 was a landmark treaty in which the Japanese leadership renounced its right and sovereignty over the Kuril Islands. However, the Japanese leadership is ever busy in propagating hatred towards Russia. Its leadership fully supports unilateral sanctions against Russia and are relentlessly supporting the enemies of Russia.

It is noticeable that Japan is an active member of the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue, or Quad. The Quad includes four countries, namely the US, Australia, Japan, and India. The US, Australia, and Japan collectively intend to increase their naval presence in the North Pacific, where Russia’s Eastern Fleet is located at Vladivostok.

It is a fact that the Japanese are very good at falsifying facts and launching a series of propaganda campaigns to malign the Russian foreign policy and Moscow’s utmost desire to safeguard its core national interests. Due credit must be given to the Japanese for their carefully crafted deceitful campaigns; nonetheless, lies don’t have legs to stand on.  This article is specifically aimed at unveiling the historical reality of the Kuril Islands.

It is not difficult to conclude that why Dmitry Peskov said that “Japan maintains a clearly hostile attitude towards our country.” There is an entire history to it, and we must study and learn that why Japan wants to act as a bulwark against Russia, especially in the North Pacific.

 

Simon Westwood – is a Masters student at the Dublin City University (DCU), Ireland. He is also a Research Assistant at the DCU’s Department of History

More on this topic
About the Russian ambassador’s article in the Korea Times
Erdoğan: Playing Both Sides
Guinea-Bissau President’s latest visit to Russia and prospects
Russia’s Cerberus: A Revolutionary Drone Swarm System
Japan’s National In-Security Strategy